Complete Checklist for User Acceptance Testing Best Practices

User Acceptance Testing (UAT) is the final test phase of an application before it is officially launched. According to a study by IBM, it costs four to five times more on average to fix a defect when found after release compared to catching and fixing it during the development process. Hence, identifying defects before the release can help organizations significantly avoid costly post-launch issues.

This article will present a complete checklist and best practices for ensuring an effective UAT process. This can enhance the product’s overall user experience and save the organization a lot of money.

What is User Acceptance Testing?

UAT is the last phase of testing in a software development life cycle, where end-users test the software for realistic usage. The purpose of UAT is to make sure that the software meets user needs and functions for its intended business purpose.

For example, if a company implements an e-commerce platform, UAT would involve tasks like adding items to the cart, processing payments, and receiving confirmations, all tested by actual users to ensure a seamless experience. Only when these processes work flawlessly from the user’s perspective can the software be confidently rolled out.

Why is User Acceptance Testing Important?

User acceptance testing is essential because it provides a final layer of quality assurance before software goes live. UAT enables the identification of issues that other forms of testing might miss.

Here’s why it’s crucial:

• Early defect identification: By catching issues during UAT, companies can prevent expensive post-launch fixes. Defects found in UAT are generally user-specific, often involving workflow or usability issues.
• Risk reduction: It reduces the chances of releasing software that could lead to dissatisfaction, rework, or even total project failure because it does not meet the user’s needs.
• Improved user satisfaction: Since UAT testing involves real users, it can utilize feedback received during this phase to customize the software according to user expectations.
• Stakeholder confidence: Successfully passing the UAT improves stakeholders’ confidence, as it demonstrates that the product is ready for production.

Key Components of a UAT Environment

A robust and realistic UAT environment is essential for successful testing. The main purpose of this is to mirror the production environment as closely as possible to provide accurate insights into how the software will perform once live.

Here are the key components that should be part of any UAT environment:

• Real data: Using real-world or closely simulated data ensures the software will behave as expected under actual conditions. This includes test cases for typical user actions as well as edge cases.
• Access controls: UAT should simulate actual user roles and permissions, providing users with the exact access they will have in production. This guarantees that security and authorization systems work as intended.
• Test scripts: Well-defined test scripts guide users through the UAT process. These scripts outline the specific workflows and tasks that users must perform.
• Defect management tools: Defect management tools help track and prioritize bugs found during UAT. They effectively manage the issues and keep stakeholders informed about the progress.

User Acceptance Testing Checklist

Now, let’s examine the user acceptance testing checklist, which covers all the steps necessary for a successful UAT process.

1. Define Clear Objectives

It is very important to define clear objectives before diving into UAT. This involves setting success criteria, determining the scope of testing, and setting roles and responsibilities.

How to define clear objectives:

• Identify the critical business and user requirements that the software must meet.
• Reduce these into quantifiable measures of system performance, functionality, and usability.
• Align these goals with the broader business objectives to ensure everyone is on the same page.

Best Practices:

• Success criteria: Define what success looks like. For example, if 95% of test cases need to pass without any defects, that becomes your benchmark.
• Roles and responsibilities: Delegate responsibilities to team members, users, developers, or business stakeholders for accountability and efficiency.
• Collaboration tools: Using platforms like JIRA or Confluence is an excellent way to write goals, assign tasks, and tell the team about status changes.

2. Prepare the UAT Environment

A UAT environment should mirror the production environment as closely as possible. This allows the software to be tested under realistic conditions, providing valuable insights into its real-world performance.

Steps to Create the UAT Environment:

• Infrastructure setup: Configure servers, databases, and network settings to simulate the production environment. Ensure user permissions, access controls, and data availability align with what will be seen post-launch.
• Data population: Populate your environment with real-world or dummy data that reflects typical user activity, including edge cases for outlier scenarios.

Best Practices:

• Infrastructure setup: Use tools like Terraform or AWS CloudFormation to automate server and network provisioning. These enable Infrastructure-as-Code (IaC), ensuring your environment is scalable and can easily be redeployed.
• Environment configuration: Automation tools like Jenkins can help you set up the environment quickly and consistently. Here’s a basic Jenkinsfile example to automate the environment deployment with Ansible:
  This ensures that every UAT deployment follows the same configuration, reducing human error.

  pipeline {
    agent any
    stages {
      stage('Deploy UAT Env') {
        steps {
          sh 'ansible-playbook deploy_uat.yml'  // Ansible playbook automates server setup and application deployment
        }
      }
    }
  }

• Monitoring tools: Use tools like Nagios or New Relic to track performance metrics during testing. These tools provide real-time feedback on system health, helping you catch issues early.

3. Develop Comprehensive Test Cases

Test cases form the foundation of UAT. They define what scenarios will be tested, the expected outcomes, and how testers will validate that the software meets requirements.

How to Develop Test Cases: Begin by identifying all possible user scenarios-both common and edge cases. For instance, in an e-commerce platform, this might include browsing, adding items to the cart, processing payments, and handling returns.

Best Practices:

• Detailed test case: Any test case should describe the objective, preconditions, steps, and expected and actual results. This would ensure the validation of each software function.
• Automated test cases: Automation saves lots of time when performing repetitive testing-related tasks. Automation can be done using tools like Selenium, which will reduce human errors in the test environment. Below is a simple automated test case using Selenium for searching for an item on the e-commerce site:

  from selenium import webdriver
  from selenium.webdriver.common.keys import Keys
  
  driver = webdriver.Chrome()
  driver.get("http://ecommerce-site.com")
  search_bar = driver.find_element_by_name("q")
  search_bar.send_keys("laptop")
  search_bar.send_keys(Keys.RETURN)
  assert "No results found." not in driver.page_source
  driver.close()

  This script automates the search feature test, ensuring your platform’s search functionality behaves as expected.

4. Select a Diverse Group of Testers

The effectiveness of UAT depends on who is testing the software. A broad team of testers representing different personas provides good feedback from all possible perspectives.

How to pick testers: Ensure your team represents a mix of end-users across different departments, functions, and skill levels. Allow each tester to represent some key segment of the software users.

Best Practices:

• Variety of testers: Include both technical and non-technical users. This approach helps surface issues that may not be immediately obvious to developers but could impact real-world users.
• Incentivize testers: Keep your testers engaged by offering rewards or recognition for their participation. This can improve motivation and the overall quality of the feedback.

5. Conduct Pilot Testing

Running a pilot test is crucial in validating the UAT process before full-scale testing begins.

How to conduct pilot testing: Choose a small group of testers to execute a limited set of test cases. This helps gauge whether the user acceptance testing environment, test cases, and tools are functioning as expected.

Best Practices:

• Pilot group: Select testers who are familiar with the software but can still provide objective feedback. The pilot test serves as a “dry run” for the broader UAT process.
• Refinement: Use the pilot test results to fine-tune your test cases and environment. Make adjustments based on tester feedback to ensure smoother full-scale UAT execution.

Code. As you meant it.

TestGPT

Try Now

6. Execute UAT and Log Defects

Once everything is in place, it’s time to execute UAT. Testers will perform test cases and log any defects they encounter.

Steps to Execute UAT:

• Execution: Testers perform testing by following pre-defined test scripts. They take every action in the software and note whether the expected outcomes occur.
• Log defects: Log the identified defects in a defect management system, along with defect severity ratings like critical, major, and minor.

Best Practices:

• Regular meetings: Regular meetings must be conducted with the testers and stakeholders regarding the progress about the defects detected.
• Defect tracking: This will ensure the defects are logged with as much detail as possible on steps to reproduce, along with screenshots and error messages. Here you can find an example of how to automate defect logging in JIRA:

  import requests
  from requests.auth import HTTPBasicAuth
  import json
  
  url = "https://your-jira-instance.atlassian.net/rest/api/2/issue/"
  auth = HTTPBasicAuth('[email protected]', 'your_api_token')
  
  headers = {
      "Accept": "application/json",
      "Content-Type": "application/json"
  }
  
  payload = json.dumps({
      "fields": {
        "project": { "key": "PROJ" },
        "summary": "Bug: Unable to checkout",
        "description": "Steps to reproduce the bug",
        "issuetype": { "name": "Bug" }
      }
  })
  
  response = requests.request(
      "POST",
      url,
      data=payload,
      headers=headers,
      auth=auth
  )
  
  print(response.text)

  This simple code snippet shows how to log a defect automatically in JIRA using its own APIs.

7. Review and Analyze Test Results

After the execution phase, reviewing and analyzing test results is crucial to determine whether the software is ready for production.

How to review results: Go over all the defects logged during UAT, prioritizing them based on severity. Analyze any patterns in defect reports that might point to deeper issues, such as performance bottlenecks or usability concerns.

Best Practices:

• Analytics Tools: Utilize Google Analytics or Splunk to identify trends and bottlenecks.
• Continuous feedback: Encourage testers to provide feedback about the system’s general usability instead of only reporting bugs they find.

8. Obtain Formal Sign-off from Stakeholders

Finally, before the software can be deployed, formal approval must be obtained from stakeholders. This confirms that the software meets all business and user requirements.

How to obtain sign-off: Schedule a meeting with stakeholders to present the UAT results. Provide an overview of passed test cases, any defects found, and their resolution status. Ensure that all critical issues have been addressed before seeking sign-off.

Conclusion

Having a structured checklist and adhering to best practices is essential for successful UAT. This ensures that your software meets expectations from both business and user perspectives, reducing costly post-launch defects.

Continuously refine and update your UAT process to stay ahead of evolving software needs. Keep your UAT process proactive, well-organized, and constantly improving to ensure a smooth rollout of your software.